Sustainable agri-food products: A review of consumer preference studies through experimental economics L., TORQUATI B., CHIORRI M. (2018): Sustainable agri-food products: A review of consumer preference studies through experimental economics. Agric. Econ. – Czech, 64: 554-565.
supplementary materialdownload PDF

In the last few decades, the interest of consumers towards sustainable agri-food products has been growing. This trend reflects changes in the consumption patterns, which have been deeply influenced by the increased sensitivity concerning social and environmental issues. In this sense, several studies, with different methodological approaches, have investigated consumers’ willingness to pay and its determinants for products with different sustainability labels. To systematise the obtained results, this paper offers a review of the studies that used experimental economics in studying consumer preferences for sustainable food and agricultural products. The 41 studies included in the review were selected on the basis of the pre-identified criterion according to the systematic review approach. Albeit discordant, the results show that a large share of consumers is willing to pay a premium price for products with eco-friendly and organic certifications. Animal welfare, ‘local’ production, or social certification appear to have a lower influence on consumer choice of purchasing. Additional information is able to modify consumer expectations and consequentially their willingness to pay, depending on the individual’s responsibility and awareness.

Akaichi Faical, Nayga Jr Rodolfo M., Gil José M. (2012): Assessing Consumers’ Willingness to Pay for Different Units of Organic Milk: Evidence from Multiunit Auctions. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics/Revue canadienne d'agroeconomie, 60, 469-494
Alphonce Roselyne, Alfnes Frode (2017): Eliciting Consumer WTP for Food Characteristics in a Developing Context: Application of Four Valuation Methods in an African Market. Journal of Agricultural Economics, 68, 123-142
Avitia Jessica, Costa-Font Montserrat, Gil José M., Lusk Jayson L. (2015): Relative importance of price in forming individuals’ decisions toward sustainable food: A calibrated auction-conjoint experiment. Food Quality and Preference, 41, 1-11
Barber Nelson A., Bishop Melissa, Gruen Thomas (2014): Who pays more (or less) for pro-environmental consumer goods? Using the auction method to assess actual willingness-to-pay. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 40, 218-227
Barlagne Carla, Bazoche Pascale, Thomas Alban, Ozier-Lafontaine Harry, Causeret François, Blazy Jean-Marc (2015): Promoting local foods in small island states: The role of information policies. Food Policy, 57, 62-72
Baudrillard J. (1994): Simulacra and Simulation. The University of Michigan Press, Ann Harbor.
Bazoche P., Hannus C., Pinto A.S., Berjano M., Maia R., Combris P., Giraud-Héraud E. (2010): Consumers’ willingness to pay for reduced pesticide use in the production of fresh and processed apples. In: Proceedings XXVIII International Horticultural Congress on Science and Horticulture for People (IHC2010): International Symposium, Lisbonne, Aug 22–28, 2010: 425–431.
Bazoche P., Combris P., Giraud-Héraud E., Seabra Pinto A., Bunte F., Tsakiridou E. (2014): Willingness to pay for pesticide reduction in the EU: nothing but organic? European Review of Agricultural Economics, 41: 87–109.
Bazzani C., Caputo V., Nayga Jr. R.M., Canavari M. (2017): Revisiting consumers’ valuation for local versus organic food using a non-hypothetical choice experiment: Does personality matter? Food Quality and Preference, 62: 144–154.
Becchetti L., Costantino M. (2006): Il commercio equo e solidale alla prova dei fatti. Dai gusti dei consumatori del Nord all’impatto sui produttori del Sud del mondo. Bruno Mondadori, Torino: 79–165.
Boncinelli Fabio, Casini Leonardo, Contini Caterina, Gerini Franvesca, Scozzafava Gabriele (2016): The Consumer Loves Typicality but Prefers the International Wine. Agriculture and Agricultural Science Procedia, 8, 236-242
Bougherara D., Combris P. (2009): Eco-labelled food products: what are consumers paying for? European Review of Agricultural Economics, 36: 321–41.
Breidert C., Hahsler M., Reutterer T. (2006): A review of methods for measuring willingness-to-pay. Innovative Marketing, 2: 8–32.
Brundtland Gro Harlem (1987): Our Common Future—Call for Action. Environmental Conservation, 14, 291-
Brunsø K., Fjord T.A., Grunert K.G. (2002): Consumers’ Food Choice and Quality Perception. Working Paper 77. MAPP, Aarhus School of Business, Denmark.
Cagalj Marin, Haas Rainer, Morawetz Ulrich B. (2016): Effects of quality claims on willingness to pay for organic food. British Food Journal, 118, 2218-2233
Caswell Julie A., Mojduszka Eliza M. (1996): Using Informational Labeling to Influence the Market for Quality in Food Products. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 78, 1248-
Caswell J.A., Siny J. (2007): Consumer Demand for Quality: Major Determinant for Agricultural and Food Trade in the Future? 097. University of Connecticut, Charles J. Zwick Center for Food and Resource Policy. Available at (accessed Nov 24, 2017).
Chen Mo, Yin Shijiu, Xu Yingjun, Wang Zhiwei (2015): Consumers’ willingness to pay for tomatoes carrying different organic labels. British Food Journal, 117, 2814-2830
Cicia G., Cembalo L., Del Giudice T., Verneau F. (2012): Il sistema agroalimentare ed il consumatore postmoderno: nuove sfide per la ricerca e per il mercato. Economia Agro-Alimentare, 1: 117–142.
Costanigro M., Kroll S., Thilmany D., Bunning M. (2010): Do Taste buds trump labels and information? A sensory test and economic experiment on organic and local apples. In: Proceedings 2010 Annual Meeting, Agricultural and Applied Economics Association, Denver, Colorado, July 25–27, 2010.
Croson R. (2002): Why and how to experiment: methodologies from experimental economics. University of Illinois Law Review, 2012: 921–946.
DE MAGISTRIS TIZIANA, DEL GIUDICE TERESA, VERNEAU FABIO (2015): The Effect of Information on Willingness to Pay for Canned Tuna Fish with Different Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) Certification: A Pilot Study. Journal of Consumer Affairs, 49, 457-471
Verneau and Professor Christopher J Fabio, de-Magistris Tiziana, Gracia Azucena (2016): Consumers’ willingness to pay for light, organic and PDO cheese. British Food Journal, 118, 560-571
Del Giudice T., La Barbera F., Vecchio R., Verneau F. (2016): Anti-waste labelling and consumers’ willingness to pay (WTP). Journal of International Food & Agribusiness Marketing, 28:149–163.
Di Nallo E. (2005): Gestire le contraddizioni: la responsabilità dell’impresa nella società dei consumi. In: Paltrinieri R., Parmigiani M.L. (eds): Sostenibilità ed etica? Per un’analisi socioeconomica della responsabilità d’impresa, Carocci, Roma.
Disdier A.-C., Marette S. (2012): Globalisation issues and consumers' purchase decisions for food products: evidence from a laboratory experiment. European Review of Agricultural Economics, 40, 23-44
Disdier Anne-Célia, Marette Stéphan, Millet Guy (2013): Are consumers concerned about palm oil? Evidence from a lab experiment. Food Policy, 43, 180-189
Elbakidze L., Nayga R.M. (2012): The effects of information on willingness to pay for animal welfare in dairy production: Application of nonhypothetical valuation mechanisms. Journal of Dairy Science, 95, 1099-1107
Elbakidze Levan, Nayga Rodolfo M., Li Hao (2013): Willingness to Pay for Multiple Quantities of Animal Welfare Dairy Products: Results from Random N th-, Second-Price, and Incremental Second-Price Auctions. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics/Revue canadienne d'agroeconomie, 61, 417-438
Elliott R. (1999): Symbolic meaning and postmodern consumer culture. In: Brownlie D., Saren M., Wensley R., Wittington R. (eds): Rethinking Marketing: Towards Critical Marketing Accountings. Sage Publications Ltd., London: 112–125.
Evans G., Kermarrec C., Sable T., Cox D.N. (2010): Reliability and predictive validity of the Food Technology Neophobia Scale. Appetite, 54, 390-393
Feldmann Corinna, Hamm Ulrich (2015): Consumers’ perceptions and preferences for local food: A review. Food Quality and Preference, 40, 152-164
Frey B.S., Stutzer A. (2002): What can economists learn from happiness research? Journal of Economic literature, 40: 402–435.
Frey B.S., Stutzer A. (2006): Economia e Felicità. Come l’economia e le istituzioni influenzano il benessere. Il sole 24 ore, Milano: 1–275.
Georgescu-Roegen N. (1968): Utility. In: International Encyclopaedia of Social Sciences. McMillian and Free Press, New York, 16: 236–267.
Gifford Katie, Bernard John C. (2011): The effect of information on consumers' willingness to pay for natural and organic chicken. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 35, 282-289
Gracia Azucena, Loureiro Maria L., Nayga Jr. Rodolfo M. (2011): Valuing an EU Animal Welfare Label using Experimental Auctions. Agricultural Economics, 42, 669-677
Gracia Azucena (2014): Consumers’ preferences for a local food product: a real choice experiment. Empirical Economics, 47, 111-128
Grebitus Carola, Lusk Jayson L., Nayga Rodolfo M. (2013): Effect of distance of transportation on willingness to pay for food. Ecological Economics, 88, 67-75
Grunert K.G., Larsen H.H., Madsen T.K., Baadsgaard A. (1996): Market Orientation in Food and Agriculture. Kluwer Academic, Norwell, Massachusetts: 1–284.
Higgins J.P.T., Green S. (eds) (2006): Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions 4.2.6. The Cochrane Library, Issue 4, 2006. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., Chichester, UK: 1–256.
Hobbs Jill E., Sanderson Kim, Haghiri Morteza (2006): Evaluating Willingness-to-Pay for Bison Attributes: An Experimental Auction Approach. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics/Revue canadienne d'agroeconomie, 54, 269-287
Kottala S.Y., Singh R. (2015): A review of sustainability, deterrents, personal values, attitudes and purchase intentions in the organic food supply chain. Pacific Science Review B: Humanities and Social Sciences, 1: 114–123.
Lange C., Combris P., Issanchou S., Schlich P. (2015): Impact of information and in-home sensory exposure on liking and willingness to pay: The beginning of Fairtrade labeled coffee in France. Food Research International, 76, 317-324
List J.A., Gallet C.A. (2001): What experimental protocol influence disparities between actual and hypothetical stated values? Environmental and Resource Economics, 20: 241–254.
Lusk Jayson L. (2003): Using Experimental Auctions for Marketing Applications: A Discussion. Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics, 35, 349-360
Lusk J.L., Hudson D. (2004): Willingness-to-pay estimates and their relevance to agribusiness decision making. Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy, 26: 152–169.
Maietta O.W. (2004): Il consumatore etico e il marketing agro-alimentare In: Antonelli G. (ed.): Marketing Agro-Alimentare: Specificità e Temi di Analisi. F. Angeli, Milano: 187–211.
Marette Stéphan, Martin Christophe, Bouillot Fabienne (2017): Two experiments in one: How accounting for context matters for welfare estimates. Food Policy, 66, 12-24
McFadden Jonathan R., Huffman Wallace E. (2017): Willingness-to-pay for natural, organic, and conventional foods: The effects of information and meaningful labels. Food Policy, 68, 214-232
Morwitz V.G. (2001): Methods for forecasting from intentions data. In: Armstrong J.S. (ed.): Principles of Forecasting, 30. Springer, Boston MA: 1–24.
Moser Riccarda, Raffaelli Roberta (2012): Consumer preferences for sustainable production methods in apple purchasing behaviour: a non-hypothetical choice experiment. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 36, 141-148
Napolitano F., Pacelli C., Girolami A., Braghieri A. (2008): Effect of Information About Animal Welfare on Consumer Willingness to Pay for Yogurt. Journal of Dairy Science, 91, 910-917
Napolitano F., Braghieri A., Piasentier E., Favotto S., Naspetti S., Zanoli R. (2010): Effect of information about organic production on beef liking and consumer willingness to pay. Food Quality and Preference, 21, 207-212
Norwood F. Bailey, Lusk Jayson L. (2011): A calibrated auction-conjoint valuation method: Valuing pork and eggs produced under differing animal welfare conditions. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 62, 80-94
Olesen Ingrid, Alfnes Frode, Røra Mia Bensze, Kolstad Kari (2010): Eliciting consumers' willingness to pay for organic and welfare-labelled salmon in a non-hypothetical choice experiment. Livestock Science, 127, 218-226
Ortega David L., Wolf Christopher A. (2018): Demand for farm animal welfare and producer implications: Results from a field experiment in Michigan. Food Policy, 74, 74-81
Reheul D., Mathijs E., Relaes J. (2001): Elements for a future view with respect to sustainable agri-and horticulture in Flanders. Report from the project Sustainable Agriculture. Stedula, Ghent.
Rutström E. Elisabet (1998): Home-grown values and incentive compatible auction design. International Journal of Game Theory, 27, 427-441
Sackett H. (2013): Willingness to pay for sustainably produced foods: an economic application in experimental auctions: an application in experimental auctions. In: Proceedings of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute Annual Meetings, Forty-Second Annual Meeting, April 5–7, 2013, New York: 1161–1177.
Schaafsma Marije, Brouwer Roy, Liekens Inge, De Nocker Leo (2014): Temporal stability of preferences and willingness to pay for natural areas in choice experiments: A test–retest. Resource and Energy Economics, 38, 243-260
Schmit Todd M., Rickard Bradley J., Taber John (2013): Consumer Valuation of Environmentally Friendly Production Practices in Wines, considering Asymmetric Information and Sensory Effects. Journal of Agricultural Economics, 64, 483-504
Siegrist Michael, Keller Carmen, Kiers Henk A.L. (2006): Lay people's perception of food hazards: Comparing aggregated data and individual data. Appetite, 47, 324-332
Tait P., Saunders C., Guenther M., Rutherford P., Miller S. (2016): Exploring the impacts of food label format on consumer willingness to pay for environmental sustainability: A choice experiment approach in the United Kingdom and Japan. International Food Research Journal, 23: 1787–1796.
Uchida Hirotsugu, Roheim Cathy A., Wakamatsu Hiroki, Anderson Christopher M. (2014): Do Japanese consumers care about sustainable fisheries? Evidence from an auction of ecolabelled seafood. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, 58, 263-280
van Doorn Jenny, Verhoef Peter C. (2011): Willingness to pay for organic products: Differences between virtue and vice foods. International Journal of Research in Marketing, 28, 167-180
Vecchio Riccardo (2013): Determinants of willingness-to-pay for sustainable wine: Evidence from experimental auctions. Wine Economics and Policy, 2, 85-92
Vecchio Riccardo, Annunziata Azzurra (2015): Willingness-to-pay for sustainability-labelled chocolate: an experimental auction approach. Journal of Cleaner Production, 86, 335-342
Vraneševic´ Tihomir, Stančec Ranko (2003): The effect of the brand on perceived quality of food products. British Food Journal, 105, 811-825
Xue H., Mainville D.Y., You W., Nayga Jr. R.M. (2010): The influence of endogenous nutrition knowledge on consumers’ willingness-to-pay for grass-fed beef. In: Proceedings 2010 Annual Meeting, Agricultural and Applied Economics Association, Denver, July 25–27, 2010.
Yiridoe Emmanuel K., Bonti-Ankomah Samuel, Martin Ralph C. (2005): Comparison of consumer perceptions and preference toward organic versus conventionally produced foods: A review and update of the literature. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems, 20, 193-205
Zepeda Lydia, Deal David (2009): Organic and local food consumer behaviour: Alphabet Theory. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 33, 697-705
Zhou Guzhen, Hu Wuyang, Huang Wenchao (2016): Are Consumers Willing to Pay More for Sustainable Products? A Study of Eco-Labeled Tuna Steak. Sustainability, 8, 494-
supplementary materialdownload PDF

© 2019 Czech Academy of Agricultural Sciences